# All channels
Sachin D. Shinde@sachin-shinde
Apollo Gateway in managed mode causes some errorsNovember 8, 2019 at 11:10pm (Edited 8 months ago)
As the docs on managed federation say, if no arguments are provided to the ApolloGateway constructor, it should automatically pick up the ENGINE_API_KEY environment variable, connect to Apollo Engine and get all registered services. However, I am getting the following output:
- apollo-gateway: Error checking for schema updates. Falling back to existing schema. Error: When `serviceList` is not set, an Apollo Engine configuration must be provided.- apollo-gateway: Gateway successfully loaded schema.- Mode: managed- UnhandledPromiseRejectionWarning: Error: Expected undefined to be a GraphQL schema.
Any suggestions what I am doing wrong?
January 8, 2020 at 4:27am
I've been getting the exact same error for days. From the documentation: When you initialize your Apollo gateway with a Graph Manager apiKey instead of a serviceList... I'm assuming they are referring to when you pass in an API key to the Apollo Server? I'm not sure. The documentation surrounding these features is poor.
January 31, 2020 at 10:30pm
Hi ... I have the same problem. According to the documentation I think this should be all.. I also debugged the code of the Gateway... there is a loadServicesFromStorage() implementation, that basically connects to Google Storage (GCS) and tries to download the latest schema... it uses the engine api key provided by the env-variable (this works) and it is able to download a secret in the first step. Then the Gateway composes a new Google Storage URL using that secret and tries to download a "composition-config-link", which fails in my case with a AccessDenied Response from GCS. The next step would be to finally download the service definitions, but this is not happening due to the failure before... In general I expect that this is a misconfiguration of Apollo with their Google Storage items (?)... or the managed mode is not really fully implemented / released by apollo and thus not working yet at all ? I have not found anyone in the web yet, that has made it work... btw. I tried with the latest gateway (0.11.7)
February 4, 2020 at 10:41pm
April 16, 2020 at 3:48pm