menu
announcement

Spectrum is now read-only. Learn more about the decision in our official announcement.

Gatsby

Fast in every way that matters. Gatsby is a free and open source framework based on React that helps developers build blazing fast websites and apps.

Channels
Team

What's The Best Way to Make Commenting System

November 21, 2017 at 12:37am

What's The Best Way to Make Commenting System

November 21, 2017 at 12:37am (Edited 5 years ago)
Hello folks..,
I have a plan to make commenting system on my blog. Since Gatsby is a static site generator, is that possible to achieve that? If yes, what's the best way to achieve so?
Any kinds of direction will be appreciated.
Thanks!
Show previous messages

November 21, 2017 at 4:04am
disqus also provides like logic.
if you want to use something else, yeah you would need back-end
Interesting.. Thanks Necmettin, will consider that thoroughly. 🙏🏻
like-fill
1
you're welcome.
like-fill
1

November 21, 2017 at 3:35pm
Hey, if you're familiar with WordPress, it seems like it wouldn't take too much time to hook into their build-in commenting system.
*built-in*
It looks like you'd send a POST request through a form from your Gatsby site to your WP backend, which would have to have the 'post_id', 'author_name', and 'content'. There are other options that you could make required: http://v2.wp-api.org/reference/comments/
I've build a plugin to hook into the 'save_post' action to send a POST request to an endpoint when a post is created, deleted, or updated. Using Netlify, you could have the site auto-rebuild: https://www.netlify.com/docs/webhooks/
I think you'd need to modify my plugin (https://github.com/benforshey/JAMstack-WordPress) to also hook into the 'edit_post' action, because it looks like that's the one that WP fires when a comment is added or updated: https://codex.wordpress.org/Plugin_API/Action_Reference (search for "edit_post").
And full disclaimer: I haven't build this. It just looks like it wouldn't be a huge amount of effort, since WP is providing all the backend infrastructure already.
I updated my plugin to send POST notifications when comments were approved, unapproved, and deleted. If you template it out, you could have a pretty easy commenting system, I think. Still haven't built it myself, though. :-)

November 22, 2017 at 2:34am
Hey Ben , thank you so much for giving some insights! I'm not a WP fan, but will definitely consider this.. 😊👌🏻
like-fill
1
Yeah, I really wasn't either until Gatsby v1. :-) But it's pretty awesome as a CMS (with a little tweaking).

January 19, 2018 at 3:43am
Hello and and , I built an open source commenting system for Gatsby. Here's a demo video & instructions: http://gatsby.demo.talkyard.io/demo-and-installation/.
What are your thoughts? Feedback please :-) if you have time.
What do you like about it? Or what's the main reason you would hesitate to use it?
If you want to use it and/or have questions, I'd be happy to help you. There's hosting too, if you don't want to provide your own server.
No ads, no tracking, & more lightweight than Disqus, + some new features (work in progress), see: https://www.effectivediscussions.org/-32/how-hacker-news-can-be-improved-3-things
like-fill
1
I was gonna say Disqus is your best choice but Talkyard is awesome too. I think both can are good & there are many different alternatives I've found Googling but Gatsby is all about making your site fast so if you're using Comments, don't fetch it first. Just use a button below "Show All Comments" & then when someone clicks you can fetch all the comments. Whether its Disqus or something else. Also, if you want to learn something build your own 😉
if you see any benefits with Disqus that Talkyard maybe lacks, it'd be interesting to know about — maybe it's something I can improve.
Both Talkyard and Disqus load comments after the main page has loaded, so doesn't affect the initial load.
(B.t.w. if someone wants not just embedded comments, but a forum/chat/Q&A site next to the embedded blog coments, with the same logins, then that works with Talkyard.)
Ohh that's good to know
& awesome job on Talkyard

January 24, 2018 at 1:56am
from mozilla, live on Washington Post now
like-fill
1

July 31, 2018 at 4:03am
Can I update my Talkyard link above too — it's broken, was http but https required for it to work (& apparently cannot edit old comments here in Spectrum).
https://www.talkyard.io/blog-comments (better & different link)

August 20, 2018 at 3:12pm
Hi, is there any guide to integrate Talk into a Gatsby site? I'm needing to setup something like this for a client site; unfortunately they do not have the budget for recurrent/monthly subscription (so I cannot use Talkyard).
Thank you!

August 21, 2018 at 4:20am
Hi , you write that you cannot use Talkyard, because of a monthly subscription fee. That sounds as if there's a misunderstanding. Both Mozilla Talk and Talkyard are free and open source, both of them can be installed on one's server for free. I suspect my about-Talkyard-page is confusing. So now I edited the page to hopefully remove this misunderstanding. (Is it more clear now? if you have time and want to have a look at the updated about page)
In addition to open-source & free, there's hosting, for Talkyard, which costs money. And there's hosting for Mozilla Talk too: https://coralproject.net/pricing/ — which also costs money.
So, both the same: install open source for free, or pay for hosting.
Show more messages